HRW: Bahrain King is committing Grave Injustice by Ratifying the Death Sentences
2019-07-27 - 2:41 am
Bahrain Mirror: Bahraini authorities appear ready to carry out death sentences against Ali al-Arab, 25, and Ahmad al-Malali, 24, both Bahraini citizens, Human Rights Watch said today.
The rights organization noted that security forces arrested them separately on February 9, 2017, adding that a court convicted them of terrorism offenses and sentenced them to death on January 31, 2018 in a mass trial marred by allegations of torture and serious due process violations.
Sources said there is an increased security presence around the prison. In addition, a member of al-Arab's family told the Bahrain Institute for Rights and Democracy that he received a phone call from the Jaw prison, where al-Arab is being detained, asking the family to come for a "special visit" with al-Arab this afternoon. He said that al-Malali's family received a similar phone call.
"If the executions are indeed imminent, then the king has committed a grave injustice by ratifying the death sentences of the two men despite the allegations of torture and other serious due process concerns," said Lama Fakih, acting Middle East director at Human Rights Watch. "He should right the wrong by immediately revoking the death sentences."
The Court of Cassation upheld the death sentence against the two men on May 6, 2019. Under Bahraini law, after the Court of Cassation confirms a death sentence, the decision is sent to the king, who has the power to ratify the sentence, commute it, or grant a pardon.
The organization further mentioned that local groups reported that the last time family members of death-row inmates had similar notifications, the detainees were executed within a few hours. Under article 330 of Bahrain's Code of Criminal Procedure, family members are permitted a final visit before the execution, on the day it is scheduled.
On May 30, 13 rights groups, including Human Rights Watch, wrote a joint letter to King Hamad ibn Isa Al Khalifa about the al-Arab and al-Malali cases. The groups raised their concerns about the men's death sentences given the allegations that their confessions were obtained under torture and their right to a fair trial was violated. The rights groups urged the king to commute the sentences, as the men had exhausted all legal remedies available to them.
In a letter addressed to the king on December 11, 2018, three UN human rights experts expressed extreme concern about the imposition of the death penalty on several defendants, including al-Arab and al-Malali, amid allegations that their confessions were obtained under torture. The United Nations Working Group on Arbitrary Detention and its special rapporteur on torture had similarly expressed "grave concern" about al-Arab's allegations of torture in a letter to the king on July 6, 2017.
Human Rights Watch opposes the death penalty in all circumstances because of its inherent cruelty. Bahrain's use of the death penalty is contrary to international human rights law, statements of UN human rights experts, and various UN bodies.
The UN General Assembly has repeatedly said that countries should declare a moratorium on the death penalty, progressively restrict the practice, and reduce the offenses for which it might be imposed - all with the view toward its eventual abolition.
"The king's indifference to the evidence raised by UN experts and rights groups demonstrates he's not serious about reform," Fakih said. "The death penalty is an irreversible punishment that should be abolished immediately, and the two young men should be spared such a cruel death."